Construction Costs
The energy saving potential of passive solar homes is explained on the Sun-Inspired Benefits page to range between 50% and 90%, but what about the costs? Is it really worth it to build a home that utilizes the sun which is passively transferred through south facing windows? Well, yes! But let's look further.
Passive solar as a low-cost green feature
Increasingly, mainstream media is beginning to point out that there is very little extra cost associated with adding passive solar when it is designed into a house plan from the beginning. Even though Les Christie, staff writer for CNNMoney.com, wrote "Green homes face a red light", he went on to discuss low cost alternatives: "Because of the appraisal issues, developers often opt for installing only the lowest-cost green features." Other professionals agree with Christie. "Some can be incorporated without much additional cost," said Curt Jones, a Connecticut-based civil engineer and green building consultant. As he describes the process for green certification, points are given for a wide variety of factors, some costing a lot, others costing nothing.
"Angling the home a little differently, for example, to catch more rays and help heat the house passively, may not cost the builder a dime."
Alex Wilson with Environmental Building News in his article "Does Green Building Have to Cost More?" states:
"If we spend more money on the building envelope (more insulation,
tighter construction detailing, and better windows) so that we
dramatically reduce the heating and cooling loads, we can often save
money on the heating and cooling equipment. With a really tight,
energy-efficient house, for example, we might be able to eliminate the
$10,000 to $15,000 distributed heating system in favor of one or two
simple, through-the-wall-vented, high-efficiency gas space heaters, or
even a few strips of electric resistance heat."
Smaller is less expensive to build and operate
Choosing a smaller plan will yield the lowest construction and energy costs. Choose a plan with the smallest footprint with everything needed on a daily basis on the first floor. Then rethink if it is truly necessary to have all the spaces on the main level. While planning for aging has been a priority for many clients of Sun Plans, many do so with a healthy dose of practicality and most of the Sun Plans reflect that with their partially accessible design. Secondary spaces, such as children's bedrooms, hobby rooms, game rooms, etc., can then be placed either on a second floor, ideally nestled within the sloped roof area that may otherwise be left vacant, or in a sunny daylight basement. The footprint stays small, but the square footage increases. Sometime a future elevator is planned in.
Simpler is less expensive to construct
Consider the home's complexity. The simplest home will yield the greatest square footage for the least cost. The Select-A-SunPlan List has a column for complexity. A very rough estimate is that a home that is rated "average" may be 10% more expensive to build that one rated "simple", and one rated "complex" may be about 20% more.
Concrete slab-on-grade foundations add thermal mass and are inexpensive
The combination of high thermal mass, and low cost, makes a concrete slab-on-grade foundation one of the best choices for all climates, not just southern ones. Building codes now address cold-climate slab foundations. A concrete slab over rigid insulation is the least expensive way to incorporate a lot of thermal mass to store the sun's heat that enters in winter. In summer, the earth below is typically cooler than the outside air so the slab performs double duty of tempering the summer home temperatures, too, and walking barefoot on a slab is delightful on a hot day! But what about cold days? Some like to add radiant heating in the slab for those inclined to go barefoot in winter, but another, much less expensive solution is to wear slippers or comfy indoor shoes with cushions. Even hardwood floors, which people often choose saying that they are more forgiving, are designed very stiff today to avoid the squeaks and bounce of older floor, so a concrete slab may not be very different in the end. Concrete slab can be inexpensively finished with stains or elaborately covered with decorative tiles.
Interior and exterior finishes affect cost more than energy-related elements
Calculate all of the spaces, inside and out, that must be constructed, and not just the finished living areas. Calculate the cost-per-square-foot range from local builders to build each of the various types of spaces such as finished areas, porches, garages, deck, and finished or unfinished. (Sun Plans often assists with this through Consulting Services.)
Although some builders may understandably be reluctant to provide exact numbers, they should be willing to give you a range in $/s.f. based on recently completed homes for other clients. Show them a Review Set with the construction information. Even though the review set will not have the Custom Specs, a builder should still be able to estimate within 10% if they are also providing a list of finishes and fixtures anticipated, since those will have more effect on the final price than the energy details. Creating such a list can be applied to any home design, so it is it worth spending time on early in the planning process. Treating the builder as a consultant by possibly paying for the estimating services should result in the most accurate pricing.
Attention to insulation and sealing adds most of the costs
It's hard to isolate just the passive solar components since it is not recommended to add passive solar until a home's "envelope" - the surfaces (walls, roofs, floors) that surround the living spaces - is properly insulated and sealed. A good "container" is needed to hold the free energy. Holes in a bucket would be fixed before adding water. To create a good envelope, it takes a little extra time and typically a little more money from the home owner to install the insulation carefully and to caulk, seal and pay attention to air leaks. And as long as the insulated cavities are being sealed up "for good," if there is room without compressing it, why not put a little extra insulation in too?
Upgrade or add finishes later for tight budgets
Visible surfaces and products can be upgraded or replaced later if the initial budget is tight, but the wall, floor, rafter cavities and certainly below-grade floors may never have another opportunity for upgrades without a major renovation. Almost the only space that is easily upgraded with insulation is an open attic - usually those with a "truss framed" roof as is mentioned under the Detail descriptions of the Sun Plans.
Lower cost heating system
The additional energy required to heat the home can be greatly reduced with the combination of increased insulation, air sealing and a proper design of whatever type of supplementary or auxiliary system is used. Even the best-performing passive solar homes will still need some form of heating from electricity, gas or wood in addition to the sun, but much less of it. Heating systems can be downsized. For those engaging Sun Plans in Create-A-SunPlan or Adapt-A-SunPlan, an HVAC consulting service is available.
Alex Wilson with Environmental Building News states in an article "Does Green Building Have to Cost More":
"If we spend more money on the building envelope (more insulation,
tighter construction detailing, and better windows) so that we
dramatically reduce the heating and cooling loads, we can often save
money on the heating and cooling equipment. With a really tight,
energy-efficient house, for example, we might be able to eliminate the
$10,000 to $15,000 distributed heating system in favor of one or two
simple, through-the-wall-vented, high-efficiency gas space heaters, or
even a few strips of electric resistance heat."
Planning
When in doubt, add more time! The cost of planning, which includes thorough research and pricing, should also be considered. Planning takes your time. Often, a higher cost can be associated with a lack of planning. Having Construction Prints at least two months prior to
starting construction is a minimum. This allows for site work and engineering time. Six months would probably be more reasonable. Engineering analysis and review of
your location and house plan may add changes due to such factors as high
winds, snow loads, seismic activity or unstable soils. Building a home is a big investment. Spend your time and money wisely.
As with building any home, it's recommended to have a contingency fund of 5-10% to cover the unknowns and extras that always come up during construction.
Below are share examples of home constructed in rural areas where costs are rather low. Estimates may vary substantially based on labor costs and finishes.
The above examples are for simple to average quality of interior finishes. Some clients choose to go far beyond these costs per s.f., but we have not heard of any Sun Plan costing more than $160/s.f. when the total cost (excluding land and site work and utilities) is divided by all area under roof, not just the finished living area which of course would make the price per s.f. much higher.
Cost-effectiveness
Passive solar homes typically result in energy savings from 40 to 75% over a minimum code-built home, when combined with above-code, energy-efficient
construction. The additional construction costs associated with such standards as Energy Star for energy-efficient construction and passive solar
design are typically 0 to 10%.
Why ask about cost-effectiveness at all? Isn't it okay to want a sunny home just because you want it? After all, is the cabinet maker asked if the large island is cost-effective? Or the bath fixture supplier asked if it is cost-effective to have both a shower and large tub? If you want the sun coming into your home, simply request it. It adds no extra square footage unlike the features just described and will bring delight for days to come.
Budgeting for a Sun-Inspired Home
While the most accurate method for obtaining the cost to build a sun-inspired home is to ask the proposed builder(s) to prepare an estimate (and paying for it will result in a more comprehensive estimate) from a Review Set, often an approximate cost range is desired even before that point. (See further info on this page.) The two biggest variables of labor pricing and interior finishes make estimates that do not consider those local factors inaccurate.
As with any consultant, if
the builder is paid for his or her time, then a better estimate should be received. Those type of planning fees are typically
money well spent.
When building a new
home, the total planning fees should approximately equal the 6-7%
realtor's fee built into the price of an existing home and these planning fees can be
financed in with the loan. For example, in addition to the house plans
and architectural fees, other planning fees might include one or more
of the following: surveying, soil testing for both septic percolation
and soil bearing, structural engineering, construction estimating,
building permits, home energy rating and interior design. An
experienced builder is the main ally in obtaining these other services
and Sun Plans can also provide opinions.
Because the question is asked so often, there must be a misconception that sun-inspired homes cost more to build than other homes. While it is true that some clients choose very high end finishes and that homes rated "complex" in our List of House Plans would cost more per s.f. than another plan of equal size, homes rated "average" or "simple" would be very similar in cost to other homes built to Energy Star standards. Of course building beyond Energy Star would cost more and at that point the engagement of a trusted builder becomes necessary with fine tuning of the budget.
The builder will at least
have to price to code
minimum insulation values for the rough estimate. An overview of the IECC insulation minimums by Climate Zone can be found in
the link
on the map to the right. This is a good general guide although
specific code requirements in your area may vary. Our Custom Energy
Specs typically exceed these since as a rule we aim for the newer 2011 Energy
Star requirements as a minimum.
Our specs also address the SHGC (solar heat gain coefficient) of the
south-facing windows in detail to allow in the winter sun.
Our specs also address the SHGC (solar heat gain coefficient) of the
south-facing windows in detail to allow in the winter sun. Some clients like to have the estimating prepared from the Construction Prints since the Custom Energy Specs are included and their is less guess work in the energy recommendations, but in any case, allow about 5% for exceeding the minimums.
What if I do not have a "trusted builder" or prefer not to pay someone for an estimate?
The following information may help with a "guestimate", but allow more room for error.
Once the price per s.f. of another home recently built is known, it can be easier to compare them by dividing the total cost of the house (less land) by the area under roof. And remember that garages, porches, finished basements are not free. Also realize that these are preliminary estimates. It is not reasonable to ask a builder to firmly price a plan unless they have not only the Custom Energy Specs, but also a list of the type of finishes and fixtures that proposed. It's never too early to get started on that list. Ask the builder or the bank if they have a standard spec form for gathering information to price.
As with building any home, it's recommended to have a contingency fund of 5-10% to cover the unknowns and extras that always come up during construction.
Below are share examples of home constructed in rural areas where costs are rather low. Estimates may vary substantially based on labor costs and finishes.
Example 1 - stud framed walls, rafter framed roof, 1.5 story, slab/crawl foundation
Interior first and second floor = 2000 s.f.
Porches = 150 s.f.
Total s.f. under roof = 2150 s.f.
Garage = None
Decks = 200 s.f.
Construction costs per s.f. of home built to approx. Energy Star standards $205,000 or about $95/s.f.
Example 2 - stud framed walls, truss framed roof, 1 story with full basement
First Floor = 1950 s.f.
Porches = 500 s.f.
Garage = 850 s.f.
Finished Basement = 1600 s.f.
Total s.f. under roof = 4900 s.f.
Construction costs per s.f. of home built to approx. Energy Star standards $350,000 or about $72/s.f.
The above examples are for simple to average quality of interior finishes. Some clients choose to go far beyond these costs per s.f., but we have not heard of any Sun Plan costing more than $160/s.f. when the total cost (excluding land and site work and utilities) is divided by all area under roof, not just the finished living area which of course would make the price per s.f. much higher.
It is has been shown that the monthly energy-savings exceed any additional monthly mortgage costs to finance any extra energy features. It may increase the monthly mortgage payment by $50/month to finance an extra $10,000 for energy upgrades, but the energy savings the first month have been typically shown to far exceed that and the savings will only increase as does the price of energy.
What if you find out that you cannot build the plans that you just
purchased?
It is certainly better to find this out prior to starting construction! A smaller or simpler home may need to be chosen. Review Set prices can be credited to the Construction Prints of
another design. And if a second Review Set is order, that can usually be credited also. If the Construction
Prints or CAD Files have already been purchased, Sun Plans allows a substantial credit on
"blueprints" of another Sun Plan through our Clunker Trade-In! (See all Specials)
In summary, if someone can afford to build a new home at all (this
is between the home owner and their bank or financial adviser), then
they can afford to build a Sun Plan. Or as some may say in relation to
the reduced operating costs, they cannot afford NOT build a
sun-inspired home.
To read more about Construction Cost of passive solar features, see Chapter 3 of The Sun-Inspired House.
(Costs for active solar, such as panels for creating electricity and heating water, are an entirely different cost system and are not addressed here. Home owners will need to consult with a local solar installer if they intend to also include active systems. $10,000 seems to be an average for a solar hot water system and photovoltaic systems seem to be averaging around $40,000 with with very wide ranges based on state tax incentives, whether or not the home will be off the grid, and the of the system which is largely determined by not only the equipment an appliances installed, but the lifestyle of the owners.)




